Where Does Depression Originate? Insights From Anti-Physiology and Cognitive Contrast Perspectives
Article information
INTRODUCTION
Depression has traditionally been understood as a consequence of cognitive distortions or negative emotional appraisals. From this perspective, depression is understood to emerge when individuals engage in pessimistic interpretations of their experiences or encounter difficulties in regulating their emotions [1,2]. However, while this explanation has significantly contributed to our understanding of the subjective aspects of depression, it may also overlook more fundamental mechanisms—particularly from a physiological standpoint.
Despite its significance, efforts to understand depression from a physiological perspective remain limited. It may be worth questioning whether the perception of depression as inherently distressing or pathological reflects a form of social bias [3]. For instance, durian—a fruit initially avoided by those unfamiliar with it due to its strong odor—may be perceived negatively at first. However, as people become more aware of its nutritional benefits and unique value, their perception often shifts toward appreciation. Likewise, depressive feelings may not inherently represent pathological states, but rather emotional signals that, when coming face to face with conflicting physiological or cultural frameworks, are interpreted as negative or distressing [4].
To examine this hypothesis, we need a model that views the onset of depression with minimal influence from cognitive interpretation. Accordingly, the present author proposes two theoretical models to explain depression: 1) the anti-physiology model and 2) the cognitive contrast model. A conceptual diagram integrating these two perspectives into a unified framework is presented in Table 1.
THEORETICAL MODELS TO EXPLAIN DEPRESSION
Anti-physiology model
Depression can be viewed as a low arousal (or low energy) state when considered from a physiological standpoint. However, low energy itself does not necessarily lead to discomfort or distress. When this state is met with a physiologically congruent response—such as an inactive state like sleep—the body remains naturally aligned with its regulatory rhythms, and emotional discomfort may not be perceived.
In contrast, if the body maintains wakefulness or enters an active state despite being in low energy—a condition that runs counter to the body’s natural regulatory flow—this misalignment with the physiological set point may result in emotional distress or depressive symptoms [5].
This model assumes that low arousal is the default condition in depressive states and emphasizes the direction of the body’s response within this context [6]. It is not merely the presence of low energy, but whether the body’s response aligns with or diverges from that state, that determines the likelihood of depressive symptoms. Physiological systems are normally oriented toward restoring balance and conserving energy in low arousal states.
When low arousal leads to a corresponding decrease in activity—such as through sleep or other restful states—it supports physiological regulation and emotional stability [7]. Conversely, if recovery fails and the body remains in a state of sustained arousal despite low energy, this physiological misalignment may disrupt homeostasis and contribute to depressive outcomes [8].
A common example is insomnia, frequently observed in individuals with depression. Chronic sleep disruption—such as difficulty falling or staying asleep—can lead to the prolonged elevation of stress-related hormones such as cortisol, an imbalance that may further intensify depressive symptoms [9]. This pattern illustrates how a mismatch between the body’s low-energy state and the failure to achieve restorative physiological responses (e.g., sleep) can contribute to the development of depressive symptoms. The issue lies not in low energy itself, but in the disruption of its physiological trajectory, which prevents the restoration of homeostasis.
Cognitive contrast model
This model explains depression as a product of the cognitive interpretation of relative physiological change [10]. When a person transitions from a high arousal state (e.g., excitement or energy) to a low arousal state, the new state is evaluated in contrast to the previous one. The resulting perception of “lethargy” stems not from the absolute level of arousal but from this relative drop. Just as lukewarm water can feel cold after exiting a sauna, emotional experiences may emerge from how the brain interprets shifts in internal states [10,11].
Importantly, this discomfort does not always arise from conscious appraisal. This idea aligns with Joseph LeDoux’s theory of unconscious emotional processing, which posits that subcortical brain regions (e.g., the amygdala) can initiate emotional responses before conscious awareness arises [12]. Similarly, Dalgleish [11] emphasized that affective states can be shaped by bottom-up physiological signals—bodily cues such as hormonal shifts, heart rate changes, or energy depletion—rather than solely by top-down cognition. In this light, depression may emerge not only from deliberate negative thoughts, but from the brain’s automatic interpretation of internal physiological contrast.
When such discomfort is repeatedly experienced and appraised negatively, it may accumulate over time and become cognitively consolidated as a persistent depressive state. Thus, in this framework, depression is not a direct outcome of arousal alone, but a cognitively constructed emotional state shaped by contrast, context, and the brain’s integrative interpretation of physiological signals.
Integrated model
While the anti-physiology and cognitive contrast models each offer distinct insights, neither alone fully explains the complex experience of depression. To truly understand where depression originates, it is essential to consider the dynamic interplay between bodily regulation and cognitive appraisal. This integrated approach may provide the most coherent framework for making sense of depression. It is a multifaceted phenomenon constructed at the intersection of disrupted physiology and meaning-making processes [13].
To illustrate how these factors interact over time, the following three-stage framework is proposed:
Stage 1: physiological recovery
When a low arousal state (e.g., exhaustion or fatigue) is followed by an appropriate restorative response—such as sleep or inactivity—the body maintains homeostasis, and depressive symptoms are unlikely to emerge.
Stage 2: anti-physiological disruption
If sleep or rest fails to follow low arousal, this indicates a physiological misalignment—a state of arousal that conflicts with the body’s energy level. Such anti-physiological conditions can disrupt homeostasis and increase vulnerability to depressive symptoms.
Stage 3: cognitive contrast amplification
When low arousal follows a period of heightened arousal (e.g., excitement, stress), the resulting drop may be interpreted more negatively due to contrast. This shift, if appraised repeatedly in a negative light, can lead to persistent emotional discomfort and the cognitive consolidation of a depressive state.
This model provides insight into depression as a complex emotional state constructed through the interaction between bodily experience and cognitive interpretation. Notably, even if one is not consciously aware of feeling depressed, the body may still experience physiological discomfort, which may later be cognitively appraised and recognized as depression.
CONCLUSION
Reframing depression through this dual-model lens allows us to move beyond moral judgments and disease-centric thinking toward a more nuanced and multidimensional understanding [14]. Depression may not be a “problem to fix” but rather a signal—a consequence of discord between physiological rhythms and cognitive appraisals.
This framework suggests that depression is not merely an emotional reaction but a complex phenomenon at the intersection of physiological regulation failure and interpretive processes. Recognizing this may shift how we diagnose, prevent, and treat depression—not just as a disorder, but as a meaningful response to internal misalignment [15].
Notes
Availability of Data and Material
The material generated in the study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors have no potential conflicts of interest to disclose.
Author Contributions
Conceptualization: Seong Jae Kim, Ji Yun Jung. Data curation: Ji Yun Jung. Formal analysis: Ji Yun Jung, Seong Jae Kim. Funding acquisition: Seong Jae Kim. Investigation: Ji Yun Jung. Methodology: Ji Yun Jung, Seong Jae Kim. Project administration: Seong Jae Kim. Resources: Seong Jae Kim. Supervision: Seong Jae Kim. Validation: Ji Yun Jung, Seong Jae Kim. Writing—original draft: Ji Yun Jung, Seong Jae Kim. Writing—review & editing: Seong Jae Kim.
Funding Statement
This study was supported by grants from the Clinical Medicine Research Institute at Chosun University Hospital, 2023.
Acknowledgments
None
