INTRODUCTION
Anorexia nervosa (AN) is a severe psychiatric illness that is prone to pain chronification and is associated with an increased mortality risk [1]. AN occurs mainly during adolescence, with prevalence rates of approximately 1.7% in adolescents [2]. A low body weight, a fear of gaining weight and an alteration of body image are characteristics of AN. The restrictive subtype of AN (AN-R) occurs when weight loss is primarily due to diet, fasting and/or excessive exercise and, unlike the AN binge-purge subtype, includes more discrete and extreme instances of reducing intake, as well as more chronic reduction of energy [3]. Differences in body composition and psychopathology have been demonstrated between the subtypes of AN [4]. Therefore, it is necessary to differentiate the evolution of the illness between the AN subtypes to contribute to a better understanding of the symptomatology and course of AN and to find more specific treatment approaches.
Although a recent systematic review highlighted the lack of consensus on treatment protocols with respect to refeeding practices [5], the importance of rapid refeeding strategies for body weight restoration in this population is clear. Restoring optimal weight, especially in AN-R, is the key to avoiding serious physical complications in the bone mineral density, the musculoskeletal system and linear growth [6]. Therefore, monitoring these systems during the refeeding process is essential among these patients. There is currently no superior treatment setting for AN (outpatient, inpatient, reduced length of inpatient followed by outpatient, or partial hospital care [7]). However, programs based on cognitive behavioral treatment, together with family support, seem to be effective and have been recommended in the treatment of adolescents with AN [8].
In addition to inpatient care, additional goals must be completed to facilitate a movement toward full recovery [9]. The available studies examining the changes in the psychopathology of adolescents with AN in hospital environments show contradictory results. Some studies found an improvement in general psychopathology [10,11], while others did not find changes despite weight recovery [12]. Likewise, research on the efficacy and impact of interventions for AN should include evaluation of body image disturbance, in addition to changes in weight and medical stability [13].
An increase in physical activity (PA) can be considered a significant factor for the onset and maintenance of the illness [3]. Since these patients are actively trying to modify the shape of their body, PA is only one of the ways to obtain the “desired ideal thinness.” In addition, these patients may rely on PA as a key coping strategy in the face of negative affect of the illness [14]. However, few studies have objectively evaluated the changes in PA during nutritional recovery in patients with AN, and different results have been obtained [15]. As a consequence, a better understanding of PA in this population is justified during weight restoration efforts to improve outcomes for patients with AN-R.
Sleep disorders are highly correlated with AN and that there are multiple areas of sleep that AN effects compared to a healthy population [16]. In fact, sleep disorders in patients with AN have been considered an important clinical marker [17]. To date, the studies that have examined sleep disorders among patients with AN are mainly using polysomnographic monitoring [18]. However, studies are needed to evaluate sleep in a natural environment over a long period, and for this, actigraphs are a useful method for the assessment of sleep [19].
Therefore, the objective of the present study was to analyze the clinical, psychopathological, physical, and sleep-related evolution of adolescents with AN-R after 10 weeks of a daytime hospital program. We hypothesized that after the hospital program it would improve the parameters evaluated in adolescents with AN-R.
METHODS
Participants
This study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee of the University Hospital Complex of Huelva (PI 005/16) and registered in www.clinicaltrials.gov (Identifier: NCT03667183), and it followed the guidelines of the Declaration of Helsinki, last-modified in 2013. All female participants between 10 and 17 years old with restricting-type AN (n=23), who were diagnosed according to the clinical criteria of the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5)3 and who were included in the day hospital program (DHP) of the Treatment Program for Eating Disorders (TPED) were recruited from the Children’s Mental Health Unit of the Vázquez Díaz Hospital (Huelva, Spain). Fourteen subjects agreed to participate, and they and their parents signed written informed forms. The inclusion criteria were as follows: 1) clinical diagnosis of restricting-type AN in the aforementioned hospital; 2) aged from 10 to 17 years old; 3) the medical team indicated that patients were under analytical control to participate; and 4) written informed consent of the patients and their legal guardians was provided. The exclusion criteria were 1) having other mental health diagnoses and 2) consumption of narcotic drugs. All patients were assessed by the same researcher to reduce interexaminer error.
Treatment description
The DHP of the TPED is a program that has been held at the Child-Mental Health Unit of the Vázquez Díaz Hospital (Huelva, Spain) since 2001. The multidisciplinary team is composed of eleven specialized eating disorders (EDs) health professionals (one psychiatrist, one endocrinologist, three nurses, four nursing assistants, one occupational therapist and one social worker) together with a professor and an administrative officer. The main objective of the program is to reduce the problematic food-related symptoms, such as restriction, binging and purging, of children who need intensive treatment without being totally hospitalized. The DHP characteristics of TPED are described in the Supplementary material.
Procedure
The study consisted of four visits to the hospital. In the first visit (baseline), anthropometric data and body composition data were examined, and patients were monitored for energy expenditure for 9 days. The day where the portable monitor was removed, they also completed different questionnaires. The procedure was repeated 10 weeks later. The delay between admission to the hospital and baseline assessment averaged 48.7 (±11.6) days. All measurements and questionnaires were collected and supervised by qualified personnel.
Clinical measures
InBody 770 (Inbody Co., LTD, Seoul, Korea) was used to measure body composition through bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA). Multifrequency and octopolar bioelectrical impedance, such as InBody 770, has been shown to be reliable and precise in patients with AN [20]. This body composition analyzer has already been validated in children and adolescents [21]. Height was measured barefoot and in underwear to the nearest 0.1 cm following standard procedures using a balance with an incorporated stadiometer (Detecto 439; Detecto, USA). Body mass index (BMI) was calculated as body mass (kg) divided by height (m) squared.
Psychopathology of AN
Psychiatric symptoms
The self-report questionnaire Eating Disorder Inventory-3 (EDI-3) was used to analyze psychological traits and key symptoms of the development and maintenance of EDs, including AN [22]. It is composed of 91 items with a choice of 6 answers each and organized into 12 main scales: three scales specific to EDs and nine general psychological scales that are highly relevant but not specific to EDs. The EDI-3 also provides 6 composite scores: a specific one for EDs and five indices of integrative psychological constructs. We used the Spanish adaptation of the EDI-3 [22], which has high levels of internal consistency in all the diagnostic groups (Cronbach’s alpha from 0.85 to 0.95).
Body image disturbance
The Contour Drawing Rating Scale (CDRS) was used because it is one of the easy-to-administer and most popular figure drawing scales for the evaluation of body image disturbance [23,24]. This self-administered scale is composed of nine female figures viewed from the front with relatively fine increasing graduations of BMI. The person is asked to indicate which figure represents their current body shape (perceived body shape) and what figure they would like to have (ideal body shape). The discrepancy between these two classifications represents a measure of body dissatisfaction. A score of 0 was interpreted as satisfaction with body image, and a score different than 0 was interpreted as body dissatisfaction (Satisfied=0; Dissatisfied=1) [25]. The use of the absolute value of the discrepancy between the current and desired body shape was used in the analyses, as it has also been used previously [26]. The validity and reliability test-retest of the CDRS have been satisfactorily analyzed in adolescents (Cronbach’s alpha from 0.77 to 0.84) [24], and it has been widely used in clinical and healthy populations [27].
Physical activity and sleep
Free-living activity behaviors were objectively measured using the multisensor monitor Sensewear Mini Armband (SWM) (BodyMedia Inc., Pittsburgh, PA, USA), previously used in adult patients with AN [28], for a 24-hours, 9-days period, which included five weekdays and two weekend days. Sleep time and sedentary (≤1.5 METs), light (1.6-2.9 METs), moderate (3-6 METs) and vigorous (>6 METs) physical activity were recorded on a minute-by-minute basis. Sleep time variables were night sleep duration (time from sleep onset to offset), sleep latency (time from bed time to sleep start), night perturbations (number and time of perturbations after sleep onset) and sleep efficiency (percentage of time spent asleep from sleep onset to offset). Participants were told to remove the monitor only for water-based activities. Only participants who carried the monitor for at least 95% of the entire day (1,368 minutes) were included in the study. To minimize immediate reactivity to the monitor that may have altered their habitual lifestyle, we removed from the analysis the first and the last day of monitoring data.
Statistical analyses
All statistical tests were performed using SPSS (SPSS, IBM Corp. Released 2016. IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 24.0. IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA). Significance was set at p<0.05. Due to the size of the sample, we assumed a nonnormal distribution; therefore, the Wilcoxon test was used to evaluate significant differences between baseline assessment and after 10 weeks, and when there was significance, the 95% confidence intervals (CI) for the differences were calculated. Data were also assessed for practical/clinical meaningfulness using an approach based on the magnitudes the changes observed. Cohen’s d statistic determined the effect size of the standardized differences in the selected variables, and Hopkins’ scale and a customized spreadsheet were used to determine the magnitude of the effect size [29,30]. A practically worthwhile difference was assumed when the difference score of the between subject standard deviation was at least 0.2. Threshold values for Cohen’s effect size were trivial (0.0-0.19), small (0.20-0.59), moderate (0.60-1.19), large (1.20-1.99), and very large (≥2.00). Quantitative chances of positive/trivial/negative difference were assessed qualitatively as follows: <25% unclear, 25% to 75% possibly, >75% likely, >95% very likely, and >99.5% almost certainly. A substantial difference was set at >75%.
RESULTS
The average age of the 14 participants was 14.3 (±1.6) years.
The results of the clinical evolution of the patients after 10 weeks of the intervention program are shown in Table 1. A significant, small standardized and substantial increase was found in weight (p=0.009, 95% CI: -3.57 to -0.75) and body mass index (p=0.019, 95% CI: -1.27 to -0.16). Significant and small standardized increases were found in total body water (p=0.014, 95% CI: -1.29 to -0.21), body fat mass (p=0.028, 95% CI: -2.26 to -0.04), soft lean mass (p=0.011, 95% CI: -1.65 to -0.32), fat-free mass (p=0.014, 95% CI: -1.74 to -0.29) and skeletal muscle mass (p=0.010, 95% CI: -1.08 to -0.22). Moreover, there was a significant increase in height (p=0.003, 95% CI: -1.27 to -0.37) and a small standardized increase in percent body fat.
The evolution of psychopathology is shown in Table 2. In relation to EDI-3, small standardized and substantial increases were found in maturity fears, and small standardized decreases were obtained in drive for thinness, bulimia and interoceptive deficits. Regarding CDRS, there was a small standardized increase in perceived body shape and a decrease in body dissatisfaction.
Changes in physical activity and sleep are shown in Table 3. In relation to physical activity, there was a small standardized decrease in daily average METs and an increase in sedentary activity. With regard to sleep, a significant, moderately standardized and substantial increase in sleep latency was found (p=0.002, 95% CI: -16.00 to -4.10), and a significant, small standardized and substantial decrease in sleep efficiency was found (p=0.035, 95% CI: -0.04 to 5.37). In addition, small standardized and substantial increases were found in night perturbations, both in number and in duration.
DISCUSSION
This study analyzed the clinical, psychopathological, physical, and sleep evolution of female adolescents with restrictingtype AN admitted to a day hospital program for 10 weeks. The main finding, in addition to the increase in body mass, was the increase in sleep latency and, consequently, the decrease in sleep efficiency.
A major finding of the current study was that the measured sleep objectively worsened after refeeding in adolescents with AN-R. We found an increase in nocturnal latency and the number and duration of night perturbations, which is because there was a decrease in sleep efficiency. It has been reported that there is an objectively measured improvement in sleep after the restoration of weight in patients with AN [31] and that sleep disorders are related to the malnutrition observed in these patients, and, after increasing weight, sleep disorders improve [16,31]. However, Pieters et al. [18] did not observe changes in the objective variables of sleep after 20 weeks of treatment in adolescents with AN, and Lehmann et al. [32] found that the duration of sleep was inversely associated with an increase in BMI. Anxiety triggered by the increase in weight and the pressure of monitoring and control of physical activity by hospital staff and parents could be one of the explanations for the increase in sleep disorders in this clinical population after 10 weeks of refeeding [17]. Therefore, it is crucial to address sleep care in acute treatment protocols in adolescents with AN-R to potentiate the treatment efficacy for the main clinical disorder, as evidenced by other psychiatric conditions [16].
In our study we found a significant increase in eight of the ten variables of body composition, in agreement with other studies of refeeding in this population [33,34]. Contrary to our results, other study reported a decrease in total body water after weight recovery in adults with AN [34]. This discrepancy could be due to the comparison of adults with adolescents, since an increase in total body water was also reported after refeeding in adolescents with AN, and this increase was due to the increase in intracellular water [35]. Unlike our results, there was a significant increase in bone mineral content in a study of adolescents with AN; however, no changes were found in lean tissue mass after 7 months of weight gain [33]. It is likely that this result is due to the study lengths, since no changes were found in whole body bone mineral density after a 12-week intensive nutrition therapy program with AN patients [36].
We did not find any significant change in the psychopathology of the anorexia nervosa or in the evaluation of body dissatisfaction. These results agree with other previous studies in which no significant improvement was obtained after weight recovery in adolescents with AN [12,37]. However, Iniesta Sepúlveda et al. [10] observed a decrease in core pathological features, while Hatch et al. [11] obtained improvements in only two of the five psychopathological variables. Several studies have reported the existing gap between physical recovery and psychological change since they did not find significant associations between them [12,34], which could explain the high rate of relapse of AN after discharge from inpatient units. One of the reasons that can explain this gap in our results may be the short evaluation period between the two assessments of our study. On the other hand, body image disturbance does not seem to change after hospitalization in these patients [12,38]. Kodama et al. [38] found, through functional magnetic resonance imaging, that there is an alteration of body image even after weight recovery in patients with AN. In our patients, we observed a small increase in perceived body image and a decrease in body dissatisfaction. Similar findings were obtained in a previous study in which ideal body image did not change after 12 weeks of nutritional recovery, though patients did obtain an increase in perceived body image [39]. It has been reported that younger adolescents with AN perceive greater coercion than older adolescents [37], and those who have a lower weight experience less anxiety with body image than those with recovered weight [40]. Although nutritional restoration is key in the treatment of these patients, the increase in the amount of food increases anxiety and resistance to refeeding [41]; therefore, these aspects should be treated with greater emphasis especially in this clinical population in treatment programs.
Objective assessment of physical activity in adolescents with AN-R using an activity monitor revealed that there were no changes in activity after 10 weeks of refeeding, except for a small decrease in average METs and a small increase in sedentary activity. This finding contrasts with other study in which an increase in energy expenditure was found after weight recovery in adults.42 However, it seems that this increase is not directly related to the severity of the pathology nor does it seem to cause weight loss or relapse during follow-up [42]. In a study with adolescents with AN, it was reported that physical activity tends to normalize during treatment and remains stable one year after follow-up [15]. A possible explanation for not finding changes in physical activity in our study could be due to the efforts of the clinical staff not to increase the activities in the patients, since it could compromise the nutritional recovery, which is the priority, in this clinical population.
The main strength of this study is that it is one of the very few to investigate several days of sleep and physical activity (7 full days) objectively in female adolescents with AN-R before and after weight gain. In addition, our sample was homogenous and comprised drug-free, restricting-type AN patients without comorbid depression or other mental health diagnoses. Because of rapid maturational changes, sleep characteristics in young adolescents should be interpreted with great caution. A confounding variable could have been the mean time between admission and baseline assessment. During this period, patients were already in a stage of active refeeding, and this was necessary to participate in the study safely under medical supervision. In addition, if one studies patients shortly after admission, the sleep quality may be influenced by the stress of being admitted to a hospital and/or the adaptation to a new environment.
There are some limitations to be considered regarding our study. First, it is a single-arm study, and therefore, no control group was used for comparison, resulting in time as the independent variable. Second, there are known limitations of all nonprobability samples, including the unknown levels of sampling errors and their lack of representativeness. Third, the small sample in this study may be due to the low prevalence of this illness, and it is difficult to enroll a large number of affected adolescents for ten weeks. Future research should include a randomized controlled design and a larger sample of adolescents to thoroughly validate our results.
In conclusion, after 10 weeks of follow-up in adolescent patients with AN-R who participated in a day hospital program, there was a positive evolution of body composition. No changes were observed in the patients’ general psychopathology. However, regarding sleep patterns, there was a worsening of sleep latency and efficiency, so sleep care should be addressed in acute treatment programs for adolescents with AN-R.
PDF Links
PubReader
ePub Link
XML Download
Full text via DOI
Download Citation
Supplement
E-Mail
Print
